Grading Rubrics for TfU 2010

Rubrics for Component 1 (Oral interview) - 10%

	1	2-3	4
Execution of the interview	Interview was conducted in a haphazard manner. Not much thought has been put into the phrasing of the questions.	Interview was conducted in an organised manner. Some thought has been put into the phrasing of the questions.	Interview was conducted in an organised manner with an obvious underlying theme. Plenty of thought has been put into the phrasing of the questions.
Linkage	Little or no effort has been made to phrase the questions such that they are linked to the research required in component 2.	Some effort has been made to phrase the questions such that they are linked to the research required in component 2.	-
Clarity of the interview transcript	Information and answers are presented in a disorganised fashion.	Information and answers are presented in a fairly organised fashion.	-

Rubrics for Component 2 (Background research) - 15%

	1 -2	3 - 4	5
Writeup on the location of the photograph	Information does not clearly relate to the location of the photograph. There is little or no detail with little or no evidence of research. Little or no evidence of effort.	Information relates clearly to the location of the photograph. There is a good amount of detail with evidence of varied sources of research. Evidence of good effort put in.	Information relates very clearly to the location of the photograph There is excellent detail with evidence of usage of numerous sources of research. Evidence of excellent effort put in.
Writeup on the period or the era that the photograph is situated in	Information does not clearly relate to the era of the photograph. There is little or no detail with little or no evidence of research. Little or no evidence of effort.	Information relates clearly to the era of the photograph. There is a good amount of detail with evidence of varied sources of research. Evidence of good effort put in.	Information relates very clearly to the era of the photograph. There is excellent detail with evidence of usage of numerous sources of research. Evidence of excellent effort put in.
Writeup on Significance of the photograph	Information does not clearly relate to the significanc of the photograph. There is little or no detail with little research. Little or not evidence of effort.	Information relates clearly to the significance of the photograph. There is a good amount of detail with evidence of varied sources of research. Evidence of good effort put in.	Information relates very clearly to the significance of the photograph. There is excellent detail with evidence of usage of numerous sources of research. Evidence of excellent effort put in.

Rubrics for Component 3 (Reflection) - 5%

	1-2	3-4	5
Individual reflection	Reflection reveals that the student shows little or no understanding on the purpose and objectives of the TfU project. The student shows little or no effort in documenting his candid personal thoughts on the project. The student reveals little or no insight.	Reflection reveals that the student shows some understanding on the purpose and objectives of the TfU project. The student shows some effort in documenting his candid personal thoughts on the project. The student has a commendable level of personal insight.	Reflection reveals that the student has shown understanding on the objectives of the TfU project. The student shows tremendous effort in documenting his candid personal thoughts on the project. The student demonstrates maturity in his personal insight.

Choosing a photograph

Many of you will inevitably ask us, so what type of photograph will be acceptable for this project?

Let us show you a few examples.

A photograph depicting my grandmother (middle row, on the extreme right) with her teachers and fellow classmates in a university in Manado, Indonesia. This picture was most likely taken between 1930 and 1935, before Indonesia gained independence from the Dutch, which explains the Dutch professor in the picture (top row, on the extreme left).

This is a picture of my mother (on the left) with her best friend on a trishaw in Jakarta, Indonesia. This was taken in the year 1974, when Suharto was the President.

Therefore, as long as your photograph has a some form of historical significance and you are able to trace back to its origins and the events that took place that year, it should be acceptable.

All the best in choosing the right photograph!

History TfU Project Guidelines - 2010

Victoria School Sec One History TfU Project Guidelines

Term 3 Assessment components (CA):

TfU Project – 60%
CA paper in Week 8 – 40%

What is this project all about?

This project is about the use of evidence in history and the different ways in which the evidence is used to reconstruct the past.

In order to do this, you will form groups of one to four to complete this project. This project consists of a number of different components which require you to work closely with your group mates in order to complete the project.In your groups, find a photograph that is of some historical value.

This history project is about this photograph and through the study of this photograph, we hope to find out more about its origins, background and historical significance.

What kind of photograph?

Preferably a photograph that dates back to (at least) your parents' generation.
The photograph must have some form of historical significance. It is advisable to show your teacher the photograph for approval before you continue with the interview and research.
The components are as follow:

Component 1: Oral Interview (10%)

This component requires you to conduct an oral interview with a person who has some knowledge of the photograph. You may use the following to formulate your interview questions. You are encouraged to pose more questions to your interviewee.

Clearly state the year (or the period) the photograph was taken.
Briefly describe the place and what is happening in the photograph.
Identify the people in the photograph. Who were they? What were their occupations? How old were they when the photograph was taken?
(Note: More marks will be awarded to groups with well-formulated questions. A full transcript of the interview is required for grading.)

Component 2: Background Research (15%)

After completing the oral interview, you are required to do some research based on the information gathered from the interview. Do a little background research on the historical events that took place during that year and relate it to the photograph. You may use the following questions to guide your research.
How is your photograph related to or reflective of that particular year or era?
What is the historical significance of this photograph?

(Minimum number of words: 350)

Component 3: Individual Reflection (5%)

Component 3 requires you to reflect upon your learning through the completion of this unit and your group project.
1. What have you learnt?
2. Challenges that you faced throughout the project and how you overcame them?What are some of the thoughts and feelings that you have?

Assignment requirements:

All documents should be typed in Arial, font size 12, 1.5 paragraph spacing. No hand-written papers will be accepted. Names, class and register numbers have to be clearly indicated on the cover page.

Deadlines:

You will need to submit a draft of the project to your respective teacher for checking by the final week of Term 3, with Friday (3 Sep 2010) being the last day of submission. It is not necessary for you to submit a complete project but the teacher must be able to see some form of progress.

Final submission date of the TFU project: Term 4 Week 1 (17 Sep 2010)

Penalty for late submission: 10% of the total marks will be deducted for every day of late submission.